Research Papers: Friction and Wear

Slurry Erosion of Pipeline Steel: Effect of Velocity and Microstructure

[+] Author and Article Information
Tahrim Alam, Md. Aminul Islam, Zoheir N. Farhat

Department of Process Engineering and
Applied Science,
Materials Engineering Program,
Dalhousie University,
Halifax, NS B3J 2X4 Canada

Contributed by the Tribology Division of ASME for publication in the JOURNAL OF TRIBOLOGY. Manuscript received July 3, 2015; final manuscript received September 2, 2015; published online November 4, 2015. Assoc. Editor: George K. Nikas.

J. Tribol 138(2), 021604 (Nov 04, 2015) (10 pages) Paper No: TRIB-15-1240; doi: 10.1115/1.4031599 History: Received July 03, 2015; Revised September 02, 2015

Pipelines are the most flexible, economic, and convenient way for oil and gas transportation. Material degradation by slurry erosion is a common feature in oil transmission pipeline. In the present work, slurry erosion of AISI 1018, AISI 1080, API X42, and API X70 steels is investigated in terms of slurry velocity and target material microstructure. The slurry velocity and impact angle employed were 0.2, 0.29, 0.36, and 0.43 m s−1 and 90 deg, respectively. It is found that erosion rate increases with increasing slurry velocity. Scanning electron microscopy was employed to investigate the eroded surface and subsurface of the steels. Plastic deformation, microcutting, and fracture are identified as dominant erosion mechanisms. Pearlitic microstructure exhibits superior erosion resistance compared to ferrite depending upon slurry velocity and microstructural orientation.

Copyright © 2016 by ASME
Your Session has timed out. Please sign back in to continue.


Matsumura, M. , Oka, Y. , Hiura, H. , and Yano, M. , 1991, “ The Role of Passivation Film in Preventing Slurry Erosion–Corrosion of Austenitic Stainless Steel,” ISIJ Int., 31(2), pp. 168–176. [CrossRef]
National Transportation Safety Board, 1998, “ Pipeline Incident Report—Natural Gas Pipeline Rupture and Fire in South Riding,” National Technical Information Service, Alexandria, VA, Report No. PB2001-9165010.
National Transportation Safety Board, 2000, “ Pipeline Incident Report—Natural Gas Pipeline Rupture and Fire,” National Technical Information Service, Carlsbad, NM, Report No. PB2003-916501.
Lin, H. C. , Wu, S. K. , and Yeh, C. H. , 2001, “ A Comparison of Slurry Erosion Characteristics of TiNi Shape Memory Alloys and SUS304 Stainless Steel,” Wear, 249(7), pp. 557–565. [CrossRef]
Bitter, J. G. A. , 1963, “ A Study of Erosion Phenomena: Part I,” Wear, 6(1), pp. 5–21. [CrossRef]
Bitter, J. G. A. , 1963, “ A Study of Erosion Phenomena: Part II,” Wear, 6(3), pp. 169–190. [CrossRef]
Clark, H. M. , and Wong, K. K. , 1995, “ Impact Angle, Particle Energy and Mass Loss in Erosion by Dilute Slurries,” Wear, 186–187(Part II), pp. 454–464. [CrossRef]
Chen, X. , McLaury, B. S. , and Shirazi, S. A. , 2004, “ Application and Experimental Validation of a Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)-Based Erosion Prediction Model in Elbows and Plugged Tees,” Comput. Fluids, 33(10), pp. 1251–1272. [CrossRef]
Abd-Elrhman, Y. M. , Abouel-Kasem, A. , Emara, K. M. , and Ahmed, S. M. , 2014, “ Effect of Impact Angle on Slurry Erosion Behavior and Mechanisms of Carburized AISI 5117 Steel,” ASME Tribol., 136(1), pp. 011106. [CrossRef]
Mansouri, A. , Arabnejad, H. , Shirazi, S. A. , and McLaury, B. S. , 2015, “ A Combined CFD/Experimental Methodology for Erosion Prediction,” Wear, 332–333, pp. 1097–1097.
Gnanavelu, A. , Kapur, N. , Neville, A. , Flores, J. F. , and Ghorbani, N. , 2011, “ A Numerical Investigation of a Geometry Independent Integrated Method to Predict Erosion Rates in Slurry Erosion,” Wear, 271(5–6), pp. 712–719. [CrossRef]
Zu, J. B. , Hutchings, I . M. , and Burstein, G. T. , 1990, “ Design of a Slurry Erosion Test Rig,” Wear, 140(2), pp. 331–344. [CrossRef]
Levy, A. V. , and Hickey, G. , 1987, “ Liquid–Solid Particle Slurry Erosion of Steels,” Wear, 117(2), pp. 129–146. [CrossRef]
Levy, A. V. , Yan, J. , and Arora, V. D. , 1985, “ Sand–Water Slurry Erosion of Carburized AISI 8620 Steel,” Wear, 101(2), pp. 117–126. [CrossRef]
Jordan, K. G. , 1998, “ Erosion in Multiphase Production of Oil & Gas,” Corrosion 98, NACE International Annual Conference, San Antonio, TX, Paper No. 58.
McLaury, B. S. , Rybicki, E. F. , Shadley, J. R. , and Shirazi, S. A. , 1999, “ How Operating and Environmental Conditions Affect Erosion,” Corrosion 99, NACE International Annual Conference, San Antonio, TX, Paper No. 34.
McLaury, B. S. , and Shirazi, S. A. , 1999, “ Generalization of API RP 14E for Erosive Service in Multiphase Production,” SPE Annual Technical Conference and Exhibition, Houston, TX, Oct. 3–6, Paper No. 56812.
McLaury, B. S. , and Shirazi, S. A. , 2000, “ An Alternate Method to API RP 14E for Predicting Solids Erosion in Multiphase Flow,” ASME. J. Energy Resour. Technol., 122(3), pp. 115–122. [CrossRef]
Islam, Md. A. , Alam, T. , Farhat, Z. N. , Mohamed, A. , and Alfantazi, A. , 2015, “ Effect of Microstructure on the Erosion Behavior of Carbon Steel,” Wear, 332–333, pp. 1080–1089. [CrossRef]
Mazumder, Q. H. , Shirazi, S. A. , McLaury, B. S. , Shadley, J. R. , and Rybicki, E. F. , 2005, “ Development and Validation of a Mechanistic Model to Predict Solid Particle Erosion in Multiphase Flow,” Wear, 259(1–6), pp. 203–207. [CrossRef]
Desale, G. R. , Gandhi, B. K. , and Jain, S. C. , 2008, “ Slurry Erosion of Ductile Materials Under Normal Impact Condition,” Wear, 264(3–4), pp. 322–330. [CrossRef]
Desale, G. R. , Gandhi, B. K. , and Jain, S. C. , 2005, “ Improvement in the Design of a Pot Tester to Simulate Erosion Wear Due to Solid–Liquid Mixture,” Wear, 259(1–6), pp. 196–202. [CrossRef]
Desale, G. R. , Gandhi, B. K. , and Jain, S. C. , 2006, “ Effect of Erodent Properties on Erosion Wear of Ductile Type Materials,” Wear, 261(7–8), pp. 914–921. [CrossRef]
Recco, A. A. C. , López, D. , Bevilacqua, A. F. , Silva, F. D. , and Tschiptschin, A. P. , 2007, “ Improvement of the Slurry Erosion Resistance of an Austenitic Stainless Steel With Combinations of Surface Treatments: Nitriding and Tin Coating,” Surf. Coat. Technol., 202(4–7), pp. 993–997. [CrossRef]
Al-Bukhaiti, M. A. , Ahmed, S. M. , Badran, F. M. F. , and Emara, K. M. , 2007, “ Effect of Impingement Angle on Slurry Erosion Behaviour and Mechanisms of 1017 Steel and High-Chromium White Cast Iron,” Wear, 262(9–10), pp. 1187–1198. [CrossRef]
Burstein, G. T. , and Sasaki, K. , 2000, “ Effect of Impact Angle on the Slurry Erosion–Corrosion of 304L Stainless Steel,” Wear, 240(1–2), pp. 80–94. [CrossRef]
Stack, M. M. , and Abd El-Badia, T. M. , 2008, “ Some Comments on Mapping the Combined Effects of Slurry Concentration, Impact Velocity and Electrochemical Potential on the Erosion–Corrosion of WC/Co–Cr Coatings,” Wear, 264(9–10), pp. 826–837. [CrossRef]
Humphrey, J. A. C. , 1990, “ Fundamentals of Fluid Motion in Erosion by Solid Particle Impact,” Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow, 11(3), pp. 170–195. [CrossRef]
Clark, H. M. , 1991, “ On the Impact Rate and Impact Energy of Particles in a Slurry Pot Erosion Tester,” Wear, 147(1), pp. 165–183. [CrossRef]
Clark, H. M. , 2002, “ Particle Velocity and Size Effects in Laboratory Slurry Erosion Measurements OR. Do You Know What Your Particles are Doing?” Tribol. Int., 35(10), pp. 617–624. [CrossRef]
Clark, H. M. , 1992, “ The Influence of the Flow Field in Slurry Erosion,” Wear, 152(2), pp. 223–240. [CrossRef]
Gupta, R. , Singh, S. N. , and Seshadri, V. , 1995, “ Prediction of Uneven Wear in a Slurry Pipeline on the Basis of Measurements in a Pot Tester,” Wear, 184(2), pp. 169–178. [CrossRef]
Gandhi, B. K. , Singh, S. N. , and Seshadri, V. , 1999, “ Study of the Parametric Dependence of Erosion Wear for the Parallel Flow of Solid–Liquid Mixtures,” Tribol. Int., 32(5), pp. 275–282. [CrossRef]
Levy, A. V. , and Yau, P. , 1984, “ Erosion of Steels in Liquid Slurries,” Wear, 98, pp. 163–182. [CrossRef]
Levy, A. V. , Jee, N. , and Yau, P. , 1987, “ Erosion of Steels in Coal-Solvent Slurries,” Wear, 117(2), pp. 115–127. [CrossRef]
Lindsley, B. A. , and Marder, A. R. , 1999, “ The Effect of Velocity on the Solid Particle Erosion Rate of Alloys,” Wear, 225–229(Part I), pp. 510–516. [CrossRef]
Cooke, R. , 1996, “ Pipeline Material Evaluation for the Mina Grande Hydrohoist System,” BHR Group Conference Series Publication, Vol. 20, pp. 455–478.
Clark, H. McI. , and Hartwich, R. B. , 2001, “ A Re-Examination of the ‘Particle Size Effect’ in Slurry Erosion,” Wear, 248(1–2), pp. 147–161. [CrossRef]
Wong, K. K. , and Clark, H. M. , 1993, “ A Model of Particle Velocities and Trajectories in a Slurry Pot Erosion Tester,” Wear, 160(1), pp. 95–104. [CrossRef]
Wood, R. J. K. , Jones, T. F. , Ganeshalingam, J. , and Miles, N. J. , 2004, “ Comparison of Predicted and Experimental Erosion Estimates in Slurry Ducts,” Wear, 256(9–10), pp. 937–947. [CrossRef]
Lin, F. , and Shao, H. , 1991, “ The Effect of Impingement Angle on Slurry Erosion,” Wear, 141(2), pp. 279–289. [CrossRef]
Hutchings, I. M. , 1987, “ Wear by Particulates,” Chem. Eng. Sci., 42(4), pp. 869–878. [CrossRef]
Postlethwaite, J. , and Nesic, S. , 1993, “ Erosion in Disturbed Liquid/Particle Pipe Flow: Effects of Flow Geometry and Particle Surface Roughness,” Corrosion, 49(10), pp. 850–857. [CrossRef]
Stack, M. M. , Zhou, S. , and Newman, R. C. , 1996, “ Effects of Particle Velocity and Applied Potential on Erosion of Mild Steel in Carbonate/Bicarbonate Slurry,” Mater. Sci. Technol., 12(3), pp. 261–268. [CrossRef]
López, D. , Congote, J. P. , Cano, J. R. , Toro, A. , and Tschiptschin, A. P. , 2005, “ Effect of Particle Velocity and Impact Angle on the Corrosion–Erosion of AISI 304 and AISI 420 Stainless Steels,” Wear, 259(1–6), pp. 118–124. [CrossRef]
Finnie, I. , 1960, “ Erosion of Surfaces by Solid Particles,” Wear, 3(2), pp. 87–103. [CrossRef]
Tilly, G. P. , 1973, “ A Two Stage Mechanism of Ductile Erosion,” Wear, 23(1), pp. 87–96. [CrossRef]
Stevenson, A. N. J. , and Hutchings, I. M. , 1995, “ Scaling Laws for Particle Velocity in the Gas-Blast Erosion Test,” Wear, 181–183, pp. 56–62. [CrossRef]
Kosel, T. H. , 1992, “ Solid Particle Erosion,” ASM Handbook, Vol. 18, ASM International, Materials Park, OH.
Molinari, J. F. , and Ortiz, M. , 2002, “ A Study of Solid-Particle Erosion of Metallic Targets,” Int. J. Impact Eng., 27(4), pp. 347–358. [CrossRef]
Mbabazi, J. G. , Sheer, T. J. , and Shandu, R. , 2004, “ A Model to Predict Erosion on Mild Steel Surfaces Impacted by Boiler Fly Ash Particles,” Wear, 257(5–6), pp. 612–624. [CrossRef]
Akbarzadeh, E. , Elsaadawy, E. , Sherik, A. M. , Spelt, J. K. , and Papini, M. , 2012, “ The Solid Particle Erosion of 12 Metals Using Magnetite Erodent,” Wear, 282–283, pp. 40–51. [CrossRef]
Finnie, I. , Stevick, G. R. , and Ridgely, J. R. , 1992, “ The Influence of Impingement Angle on the Erosion of Ductile Metals by Angular Abrasive Particles,” Wear, 152(1), pp. 91–98. [CrossRef]
Torrance, A. A. , 1981, “ An Explanation of the Hardness Differential Needed for Abrasion,” Wear, 68(2), pp. 263–266. [CrossRef]
Liebhard, M. , and Levy, A. , 1991, “ The Effect of Erodent Particle Characteristics on the Erosion of Metals,” Wear, 151(2), pp. 381–390. [CrossRef]
Levy, A. V. , and Chik, P. , 1983, “ The Effects of Erodent Composition and Shape on the Erosion of Steel,” Wear, 89(2), pp. 151–162. [CrossRef]
Hutchings, I. M. , 1981, “ A Model for the Erosion of Metals by Spherical Particles at Normal Incidence,” Wear, 70(3), pp. 269–281. [CrossRef]
Finnie, I. , 1958, “ The Mechanism of Erosion of Ductile Metals,” Third U.S. National Congress of Applied Mechanics, ASME, New York, pp. 527–532.
Salik, J. , and Buckley, D. , 1981, “ Effects of Erodent Particle Shape and Various Heat Treatments on Erosion Resistance of Plain Carbon Steel,” NASA Technical Paper No. 1755.
Foley, T. , and Levy, A. , 1983, “ The Erosion of Heat-Treated Steels,” Wear, 91(1), pp. 45–64. [CrossRef]
Levy, A. V. , Yan, J. , and Patterson, J. , 1986, “ Elevated Temperature Erosion of Steels,” Wear, 108(1), pp. 43–60. [CrossRef]
Levy, A. V. , and Jahanmir, S. , 1980, Corrosion–Erosion Behavior of Materials, Metallurgical Society of AIME, New York, pp. 177–189.
Divakar, M. , Agarwal, V . K. , and Singh, S. N. , 2005, “ Effect of the Material Surface Hardness on the Erosion of AISI316,” Wear, 259(1–6), pp. 110–117. [CrossRef]
Gadhikar, A. A. , Sharma, A. , Goel, D. B. , and Sharma, C. P. , 2014, “ Effect of Carbides on Erosion Resistance of 23-8-N Steel,” Bull. Mater. Sci., 37(2), pp. 315–319. [CrossRef]
McCabe, L. P. , Sargent, G. A. , and Conrad, H. , 1985, “ Effect of Microstructure on the Erosion of Steel by Solid Particles,” Wear, 105(3), pp. 257–277. [CrossRef]
Hong, H. U. , Rho, B. S. , and Nam, S. W. , 2001, “ Correlation of the M23C6 Precipitation Morphology With Grain Boundary Characteristics in Austenitic Stainless Steel,” Mater. Sci. Eng. A, 318(1–2), pp. 285–292. [CrossRef]
Lindsley, B. A. , and Marder, A. R. , 1998, “ Solid Particle Erosion of an Fe–Fe3C Metal Matrix Composite,” Metall. Mater. Trans. A, 29(3), pp. 1071–1079. [CrossRef]
Lindsley, B. A. , Marder, A. R. , and Lewnard, J. J. , 1995, “ The Effect of Circulating Fluidized Bed Particle Characteristics on Erosion of 1020 Carbon Steel,” Wear, 188(1–2), pp. 33–39. [CrossRef]
Hutchings, I. M. , 1992, Tribology, Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, UK, pp. 192–193.
Bazanini, G. , 2001, “ Vapour and Air Bubble Collapse Analysis in Viscous Compressible Water,” Semina, 22(1), pp. 13–18. [CrossRef]
ASTM Standard G32-10, 2011, Standard Test Method for Cavitation Erosion Using Vibratory Apparatus, ASTM International, West Conshohocken, PA.
American Society for Metals, 1992, ASM Handbook: Friction, Lubrication, and Wear Technology, Vol. 18, ASM International, Materials Park, OH, pp. 218–219.
Grewal, H. S. , Agrawal, A. , and Singh, H. , 2013, “ Slurry Erosion Mechanism of Hydroturbine Steel: Effect of Operating Parameters,” Tribol. Lett., 52(2), pp. 287–303. [CrossRef]
Islam, M. A. , and Farhat, Z. N. , 2012, “ The Synergistic Effect Between Erosion and Corrosion of API Pipeline in CO2 and Saline Medium,” Tribol. Int., 68, pp. 26–34. [CrossRef]
Islam, M. A. , and Farhat, Z. N. , 2014, “ Effect of Impact Angle and Velocity on Erosion of API X42 Pipeline Steel Under High Abrasive Feed Rate,” Wear, 311(1–2), pp. 180–190. [CrossRef]
Clark, H. McI. , 1991, “ A Comparison of the Erosion Rate of Casing Steels by Sand–Oil Suspensions,” Wear, 150(1–2), pp. 217–230. [CrossRef]
Tan, K. S. , Wood, R. J. K. , and Stokes, K. R. , 2003, “ The Slurry Erosion Behaviour of High Velocity Oxy-Fuel (HVOF) Sprayed Aluminium Bronze Coatings,” Wear, 255(1–6), pp. 195–205. [CrossRef]
Oka, Y. , Matsumura, M. , and Kawabata, T. , 1993, “ Relationship Between Surface Hardness and Erosion Damage Caused by Solid Particle Impact,” Wear, 162–164(Part B), pp. 688–695. [CrossRef]
Sundararajan, G. , 1991, “ The Depth of Plastic Deformation Beneath Eroded Surfaces: The Influence of Impact Angle and Velocity, Particle Shape and Material Properties,” Wear, 149(1–2), pp. 129–153. [CrossRef]
Arora, H. S. , Grewal, H. S. , Singh, H. , and Mukherjee, S. , 2013, “ Zirconium Based Bulk Metallic Glass—Better Resistance to Slurry Erosion Compared to Hydroturbine Steel,” Wear, 307(1–2), pp. 28–34. [CrossRef]
Zheng, Z. B. , Zheng, Y. G. , Sun, W. H. , and Wang, J. Q. , 2013, “ Erosion–Corrosion of HVOF-Sprayed Fe-Based Amorphous Metallic Coating Under Impingement by a Sand-Containing NaCl Solution,” Corros. Sci., 76, pp. 337–347. [CrossRef]
Nguyen, Q. B. , Lim, C. Y. H. , Nguyen, V . B. , Wan, Y. M. , Nai, B. , Zhang, Y. W. , and Gupta, M. , 2014, “ Slurry Erosion Characteristics and Erosion Mechanisms of Stainless Steel,” Tribol. Int., 79, pp. 1–7. [CrossRef]


Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 1

Optical micrograph of (a) AISI 1018, (b) AISI 1080, (c) API X42, and (d) API X70 steels

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 2

Schematic diagram of the slurry erosion tester showing specimen holder, slurry flow meter, slurry inlet, and air flow meter

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 3

Air jet dynamic pressure versus slurry velocity (1 wt. % Al2O3)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 4

Weight loss versus time for AISI 1018, AISI 1080, API X42, and API X70 steel at 0.43 m s−1 slurry velocity and normal impact angle

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 5

Normalized erosion rate versus slurry velocity for AISI 1018, AISI 1080, API X42, and API X70 steel at normal impact angles

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 6

SEM micrograph of steel samples after slurry erosion: (a) formation of platelets due to plastic deformation (AISI 1018, 0.20 m s−1), (b) plastic deformation (API X70, 0.20 m s−1), (c) initiation of fracture at deformed platelets (API X70, 0.29 m s−1), (d) detachment of deformed platelets (API X70, 0.29 m s−1), (e) microcutting (API X70, 0.36 m s−1), (f) embedded abrasive particle (API X42, 0.36 m s−1), (g) crack propagation in embedded particle (API X42, 0.43 m s−1), and (h) removal of embedded particle (API X42, 0.43 m s−1)

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 7

SEM close-up image of AISI 1018 steel: (a) uniform deformation due to fluid impact, (b) flattened pearlite, (c) localized deformation of ferrite, (d) localized deformation of pearlite, (e) heavy deformation of cementite lamellae due to particle impact, and (f) deformation of cementite lamellae due to penetration of abrasive particle along the interface

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 8

SEM micrograph of the cross section of AISI 1018 steel: (a) and (b) different erosion responses of ferrite and pearlite, (c) and (d) accumulation of deformed material in ferrite, (e) abrasive particle strikes pearlitic phase, and the cross section of AISI 1080 steel: (f) fracture and deformation of cementite lamellae due to abrasive particle impact

Grahic Jump Location
Fig. 9

Effect of rebound particle on slurry erosion mechanism: (a) abrasive particle impacts on the sample surface at 90 deg angle, (b) plastic deformation and formation of vulnerable lip due to impact of abrasive particle impact and rebound abrasive particle collides with new incoming abrasive particle, (c) deflection of abrasive particle after collision, (d) deflected abrasive particle strikes sample surface at acute angle and material is removed through microcutting, and (e) and (f) repeated impact by the abrasive particle causes fracture and removed vulnerable lips




Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In